In the financial world, payment revenues have emerged as a critical component of commercial banks’ overall income streams. For many banks, payment revenues can constitute as much as 20% of their total revenue, with this figure potentially being even higher in developed countries, according to International Card Manufacturers Association (ICMA) member Ahmet Alptekin, a Linxens sales manager.
“A telling example comes from a survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, which highlighted that payment revenues accounted for an average of 38% of total revenue for commercial banks in the United States,” said Alptekin.
Understanding Payment Revenue Streams
Commercial banks typically generate revenue through two primary channels: net-interest income and non-interest income. Payment revenues fall under the umbrella of non-interest income. These revenues primarily stem from interchange fees—charges levied by banks on each other for processing credit and debit card transactions.
“The typical range of interchange fees for credit card transactions is 1.4% to 2.5%, with an average of 1.9%,” Alptekin explained. “The typical range of interchange fees for debit card transactions is .05% to .60%, with an average of .30%.”
The Evolution of Payment Processing
A notable shift has occurred in the payment processing landscape with the advent of Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) wallets. When cardholders use their mobile phones to make purchases through these wallets, banks now share a substantial portion of their interchange fee income with phone manufacturers.
“This has led to a significant impact on bank profits, as these shared revenues can constitute around 40% of the profits banks previously earned from card payment processing,” said Alptekin.
Why Banks Accepted Sharing Their Revenue
One might wonder why banks agreed to such a significant revenue-sharing arrangement. The answer lies in the evolving landscape of customer interaction and payment convenience.
“As smartphones became mainstream, banks quickly adopted them as primary channels for customer engagement,” said Alptekin. “They invested heavily in developing their own digital wallets, but these efforts often fell short in terms of providing a seamless, convenient payment experience. Issues such as accessibility, convenience and security concerns led consumers to favor phone manufacturers’ wallets over those offered by banks.”
Fifteen years ago, when Near-Field Communication technology was introduced, banks had the upper hand and refused to share payment revenues with mobile network operators. However, as smartphone manufacturers’ wallets gained traction and banks struggled to compete effectively, they had little choice but to agree to revenue sharing to retain their presence in customers’ wallets.
The Biometric Card Revolution
Now, a new opportunity is emerging for banks to reclaim some of their lost revenues: biometric payment cards. The payment card industry has matured to the point where manufacturing biometric cards in large volumes is feasible.
“Just five years ago, the production of biometric cards faced significant challenges, including limited technology, high costs and a small number of manufacturers,” said Alptekin. “This created a chicken-and-egg dilemma for banks: without widespread availability and reliability of biometric cards, issuing them to customers was impractical.”
Today, the situation is different. Advances in production technology have made it possible to produce biometric cards at scale and the costs are becoming more manageable. Banks now have the opportunity to offer biometric cards, which provide a payment experience comparable to that of OEM wallets. This shift could help banks recover lost revenue while maintaining a positive user experience.
The Strategic Advantage for Banks
For commercial banks, issuing biometric payment cards presents a strategic opportunity to enhance their competitive edge. By equipping their preferred client segments with these advanced cards, banks can potentially offset the revenue lost to OEM wallets. However, issuing biometric cards alone will not be enough.
“Banks must ensure that the user experience of their biometric cards meets or exceeds that of existing mobile payment solutions,” Alptekin said. “Those banks that successfully balance these factors will be well-positioned to negotiate better terms with OEM wallets and optimize their fee structures.”
Looking Ahead: The Future of Biometric Payment Cards
As the business case for biometric cards continues to strengthen, it is anticipated that card manufacturers will begin producing them in even larger volumes. Advances in production technology will further democratize access to high-tech payment cards, making them more accessible to banks of all sizes. Card manufacturers will play a crucial role in demonstrating to banks that they have viable alternatives to relying solely on OEM wallets for payment processing.
A Case Study and Revenue Projection
To illustrate the potential impact of biometric cards, Alptekin said to consider a hypothetical case study.
“Suppose a bank with $100 million in annual payment revenue sees a 10% increase in revenue by introducing biometric cards,” he said. “This would translate to an additional $10 million in revenue, offsetting a significant portion of the loss from revenue-sharing with OEM wallets. By effectively integrating biometric cards into their offerings, banks can not only recapture lost revenue but also enhance their competitive positioning in the payment processing market.”
Conclusion
The payment processing landscape is undergoing a transformation, and biometric payment cards represent a promising avenue for commercial banks to reclaim lost revenue. As technology advances and production costs decrease, banks have a unique opportunity to leverage biometric cards to improve their revenue streams and negotiate better terms with OEM wallets. By collaborating with card manufacturers and focusing on delivering a superior payment experience, banks can navigate this shift and position themselves for future success in the evolving payments industry.
More Insights on Card Trends
For more than 30 years, ICMA has represented the interests of the card manufacturing industry—which includes manufacturers, personalizers, issuers and suppliers—as its leading global association.
Throughout the year, ICMA members have the opportunity to share insights and knowledge by giving presentations during ICMA webcasts and events. The association’s main event is its annual Card Manufacturing & Personalization EXPO. The 2025 EXPO will take place from May 12-15 in Orlando, Florida.
ICMA offers regular educational opportunities, including ACE-Manufacturing, ACE-Personalization and ACE-Advanced Technologies training and exams at the ICMA EXPO. ICMA also offers ACE-Commercial training, which provides sales, marketing, customer service and other key personnel at ICMA member companies with the opportunity to learn the fundamentals of card manufacturing.
Learn more about the benefits of ICMA membership.